Be Careful What You Believe: A Christian Caution on Truth, Speculation, and Conspiracy Theories.
In a world overflowing with information — and misinformation — Christians are called to be people of the truth. Yet many well-meaning believers fall into traps of assuming, speculating, or even spreading ideas that have little to do with biblical or verified truths. This has become especially clear in the age of conspiracy theories, where social media is rife with claims that often rest on weak or no evidence at all.
This article is a gentle reminder: not every claim deserves to be believed, shared, or defended, and we as Christians must discern carefully between what is true and what merely seems true to some.
The Hierarchy of Truth
One reason Christians get into trouble is because we don’t always recognize the difference between strong, verified truth and weak, speculative claims. (see below for a summary)
For example:
– Facts and evidence are strong foundations for belief. Facts can be verified. Evidence can be examined. These are the kinds of truths we can stand on.
– Hypotheses and theories are reasonable ideas that may need testing and further support, but are not yet certain.
– Assumptions, speculation, and conjecture are guesses, sometimes nothing more than personal opinion or imagination of possibilities vs strong evidence. They may turn out to be false — and often are.
The danger comes when Christians treat weak ideas as if they were strong truths — especially when attaching God’s name to them.
The Lure of Conspiracies
Conspiracy theories are especially tempting because they often:
– Appeal to our fear of evil in the world.
– Make us feel “in the know” or superior to others who are “blind.”
– Stir our emotions more than our reason.
– They support what we ‘want’ to believe oppose to the evidence.
But many of these theories are built on assumptions or conjecture, not verifiable facts. For example, someone might assume that because governments have lied in the past, therefore they must be lying now about everything. Or someone might speculate that the church has a part of some secret plot.
These are not biblical truths — they are often just weak guesses, and can damage our witness if we spread them without discernment.
What the Bible Says About Truth
Jesus said plainly: “I am the way, and the truth, and the life.” (John 14:6, ESV)
And Paul warned: “Therefore, having put away falsehood, let each one of you speak the truth with his neighbor…” (Ephesians 4:25, ESV)
God calls us to truth — and to humility when we do not for sure. Pretending certainty where there is none is a form of falsehood.
Why This Matters
When Christians carelessly repeat speculation, we risk:
– Bearing false witness (Exodus 20:16).
– Damaging the reputation of the church.
– Distracting ourselves and others from the gospel.
We are called to be “wise as serpents and innocent as doves” (Matthew 10:16, ESV), which means being discerning and cautious before speaking.
A Better Way
Before believing or sharing something, you may want to ask:
– Is this a fact or just someone’s assumption?
– Is there solid evidence, or just speculation?
– Does this glorify God and point people to Him?
– Am I being humble enough to say, “I don’t know” when the truth is unclear?
Being Truthful in Our Statements
It’s not wrong to have speculations, assumptions, or opinions — but we must be honest about what they are. As Christians, we should speak truthfully by clearly labeling our words. For example, saying “In my opinion…” or “Assuming this is true, then…” helps others understand that we are offering a perspective, not stating a proven fact. Too often, we speak as if something is certain when it is really just speculation. Choosing our words carefully honors the truth and keeps us from misleading others, even unintentionally.
Final Encouragement
Dear brothers and sisters: it is good to seek the truth. But it is also good to admit when we don’t yet know the whole truth. Resist the temptation to base your Christian life or your witness on speculation, assumptions, or conjecture, just to name a few. The world is watching us — let them see Christians who care deeply about what is true, and who speak with both conviction and humility.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Understanding the difference in weight of evidence that leads to truth.
STRONGEST: High Certainty (based on truth, verification)
Fact
Meaning: A statement that can be proven true by direct evidence or observation.
Example: “Water boils at 100°C at sea level.”
Difference: Facts are verifiable and objective, unlike opinions or interpretations.
Evidence
Meaning: Data or observation that supports or proves a fact or claim.
Example: “Security footage shows the suspect entering the building.”
Difference: Evidence backs up facts or arguments; it is not the conclusion itself.
Proof
Meaning: Conclusive evidence that establishes something as undeniably true.
Example: A DNA match proving identity.
Difference: Stronger than general evidence—it leaves no reasonable doubt.
MODERATE: Based on Reasoning (less certain, but logical)
Deduction (Deductive Reasoning)
Meaning: Drawing a specific conclusion from general principles or premises.
Example: “All humans die. Socrates is human. Therefore, Socrates will die.”
Difference: If the premises are true, the conclusion must be true.
Induction (Inductive Reasoning)
Meaning: Making a generalization from specific examples or patterns.
Example: “The sun has risen every day so far; therefore, it will rise tomorrow.”
Difference: Probable, not certain. Based on patterns, not guarantees.
Inference
Meaning: A conclusion drawn from evidence and reasoning.
Example: “There are muddy footprints—someone likely came in from outside.”
Difference: We infer when something is not directly observed but logically followed.
WEAK: Based on Assumptions or Limited Support
Hypothesis
Meaning: A testable explanation or prediction, often used in science.
Example: “If plants get more sunlight, they will grow faster.”
Difference: A starting point for investigation; needs testing.
Theory
Meaning: A well-substantiated explanation backed by repeated evidence and testing.
Example: “Theory of Evolution.”
Difference: Stronger than a hypothesis; widely accepted but still open to revision.
Assumption
Meaning: A thing accepted as true without proof.
Example: “Everyone wants to be rich.”
Difference: Often unstated and can be wrong; risky to build arguments on it.
Speculation
Meaning: A guess based on minimal evidence or imagination.
Example: “Aliens may have built the pyramids.”
Difference: Lacks solid support; more imaginative than rational.
Conjecture
Meaning: A conclusion based on incomplete information.
Example: “He didn’t show up—maybe he forgot.”
Difference: A weaker form of inference; more doubtful and uncertain.
Opinion
Meaning: A personal belief or judgment that is not necessarily based on fact or knowledge.
Example: “Chocolate is better than vanilla.”
Difference: Subjective, not always supported by reasoning.
As Paul writes:
“Test everything; hold fast what is good.” (1 Thessalonians 5:21, ESV)
May we be known as people who do exactly that.
